DFW Mustang Forums banner
1 - 20 of 25 Posts

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
16,774 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 ·
I just bought a new yamaha 5.1 reciever and speakers.

Before getting this I just had my DVD player and my DVR box connecting to the TV via HDMI cables.

I like the ease of use and don't want to have the reciever on any time I want to watch tv or watch a dvd without cranking up the volume.

What I did was take an optic cable from the TV to the reciever to get the sound to the reciever for the suround sound. I poped in a movie and the surround works and if I manually put it in dolby II it works fine, but the Dolby Digital light will not come on. Do I need to go directly to the reciever then to the TV on all my inputs to get full capability?

Again I don't want to have to turn the reciever on every time I watch TV.

Thanks
BJ
 

·
yes, jluv
Joined
·
17,073 Posts
Why not have the receiver on every time?

I treat my TV as a monitor and the receiver handles all of the sound.

I know a few other people that insist on doing it your way as well, but I have never understood why.
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
16,774 Posts
Discussion Starter · #4 ·
n737nc said:
Give it a shot and see if it works. It may just pass through when the receiver is off.

Nick
well it works how I have it, I would love to go through the reciever for all my inputs but the reciever has to be on for that to work. Just don't want to have it on all the time.
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
16,774 Posts
Discussion Starter · #5 ·
jluv said:
Why not have the receiver on every time?

I treat my TV as a monitor and the receiver handles all of the sound.

I know a few other people that insist on doing it your way as well, but I have never understood why.


I don't know I thought of doing it both ways too. I just don't know :)
 

·
is chilaxing
Joined
·
3,760 Posts
I have mine hooked up both ways from DirectTV receiver.....HDMI to TV, optical to stereo receiver. I use TV only for just regular TV shows. Sports games/video games/movies I use stereo.
 

·
is chilaxing
Joined
·
3,760 Posts
When it's a Dolby Digital signal, I think the stereo tells you it's that signal. I guess he wants it to show that.

To OP,
Does your DVD player have a opical out, and does your receiver have a optical in? If it does, just plug the optical between them instead from TV. See if that works. Don't know if DVD player will send audio from both outputs at same time.
 

·
lol, this place sucks now
Joined
·
13,422 Posts
Rafa said:
When it's a Dolby Digital signal, I think the stereo tells you it's that signal. I guess he wants it to show that.

To OP,
Does your DVD player have a opical out, and does your receiver have a optical in? If it does, just plug the optical between them instead from TV. See if that works. Don't know if DVD player will send audio from both outputs at same time.

Wouldn't the stereo have to be on to see the light come on?
 

·
is chilaxing
Joined
·
3,760 Posts
Well, if the stereo doesn't receive a "Dolby Digital" signal, it doesn't show that signal. It will just show some default audio setting on stereo. Like on mine, when it is receiving that digital signal, it actually says, "Dolby Digital", if it does not, it just shows default setting. Mine would show something like, Cinema/Music or something like that, which is not a "Dolby Digital" signal.

Someone correct me it that's wrong. :D
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
16,774 Posts
Discussion Starter · #11 ·
So my best option right now would be to have my tv box go to both and have my game console and dvd player plug directly into the reciever.
 

·
Dyno Racing King!!!
Joined
·
3,675 Posts
Beej said:
So my best option right now would be to have my tv box go to both and have my game console and dvd player plug directly into the reciever.
Your best option would be to run everything to the receiver and use it for sound and the TV as a monitor as someone suggested, but ...

If you send an HDMI signal to the TV, it'll carry both picture and sound to the TV. The TV will not decode DD, so the "pass through" signal to the amp will only be Pro Logic (2/3 channel grade). If you want true digital sound, you need to run cables between the DVD/Cable box to the receiver. My setup at home is much like you described, but I have multiple monitors. I send an RGB signal to my projector since it doesn't have an HDMI input and my amp will switch RGB signals, so all video and sound run through receiver. I also plug the DVD and satellite DVR to the TV via HDMI. If I turn the receiver on, set the input mode to TV, and watch a DVD, it won't play a DD signal. If I switch the receiver to DVD mode, it plays DD sound and I see an HDMI signal on the TV or a 720p RGB signal on my projector. Does that make sense?
 

·
dead
Joined
·
14,611 Posts
Juiceweezl said:
Your best option would be to run everything to the receiver and use it for sound and the TV as a monitor as someone suggested, but ...
pretty much.

redundant wiring.
send hdmi into tv for audio and video from tv.
send optical/dig. coax into receiver for audio from receiver.

most tvs suck for passthrough.
 

·
B-WIZ
Joined
·
1,807 Posts
momo stallion said:
pretty much.

redundant wiring.
send hdmi into tv for audio and video from tv.
send optical/dig. coax into receiver for audio from receiver.

most tvs suck for passthrough.

Most tvs dont even do pass through. The optical out on tv is for your over the air tuner.
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
16,774 Posts
Discussion Starter · #15 ·
KOZMO said:
Most tvs dont even do pass through. The optical out on tv is for your over the air tuner.

ok so its prolly just passing through regular signal.

What I need to do is run an HDMI for the cable box to the TV for regular viewing, then use a component out for the cable box, dvd, and ps2 to the reciever. Is that my best option.

My reciever does have HDMI pass through, but it is video only, does that mean I still need an audio source from my dvd to the reciever?
 

·
Dyno Racing King!!!
Joined
·
3,675 Posts
Beej said:
ok so its prolly just passing through regular signal.

What I need to do is run an HDMI for the cable box to the TV for regular viewing, then use a component out for the cable box, dvd, and ps2 to the reciever. Is that my best option.

My reciever does have HDMI pass through, but it is video only, does that mean I still need an audio source from my dvd to the reciever?
The receiver should only pass through a video signal. Why would it send audio too? I may, but I don't see a point. Further, I bet in only does pass through if turned on, but again I could be wrong. If your receiver has HDMI capabilities, then it switches inputs too. If it were me, I'd plug everything (video and audio) into the receiver and ALWAYS use it for sound. Then plug one HDMI cable from receiver to the TV and let the receiver just switch everything (video and sound). If you are plugging HDMI from say DVD to receiver, then you shouldn't need an optical cable too. If you go DVD to TV and then to receiver, then yes you will need an optical cable.
 

·
yes, jluv
Joined
·
17,073 Posts
Beej said:
ok so its prolly just passing through regular signal.

What I need to do is run an HDMI for the cable box to the TV for regular viewing, then use a component out for the cable box, dvd, and ps2 to the reciever. Is that my best option.
No. The best option would be to turn the speakers on your TV completely off and use your surround sound receiver for all of your sound. You can turn it down or even set it to stereo playback if you just have some kind of thing against surround sound. Even this way, it will sound much better than the built-in speakers in your TV.

Beej said:
My reciever does have HDMI pass through, but it is video only, does that mean I still need an audio source from my dvd to the reciever?
Basically, yes. You still need to run an optical (or digital coax) cable from the source to the receiver in addition to the HDMI. They do make better receivers that do true HDMI "switching" (not just "pass-through") and they will take the sound from the HDMI cable and process it correctly. This just makes for simpler wiring and easier control from the remote. Also, HDMI will carry a full 7.1 signal and support TrueHD, but don't worry about that anyway since your receiver is not on that level.

With your setup, I would run HDMI and optical cables from each source (DVD player, satellite box, game system, etc) output directly to your receiver inputs and then run an HDMI cable from your receiver output to your TV input. Program your receiver remote to power your TV on and off, and if you can, to change channels on the satellite box and control the DVD player as well. Use your surround sound receiver every time you watch anything. The only thing I ever do to my TV is turn it on and off.

EDIT: With the PS2, I don't think you can do HDMI. You can still get a cable that connects from the PS2 to component video inputs (red/green/blue) on the receiver, and couple that with the optical audio cable.
 

·
dead
Joined
·
14,611 Posts
Beej said:
ok so its prolly just passing through regular signal.

What I need to do is run an HDMI for the cable box to the TV for regular viewing, then use a component out for the cable box, dvd, and ps2 to the reciever. Is that my best option.

My reciever does have HDMI pass through, but it is video only, does that mean I still need an audio source from my dvd to the reciever?
hdmi pass through means your receiver wont process HDMI audio, it will simply act as a video switcher.

here is how you should set up your system based on what you wanted.

HDMI from your cable box to your tv. optical/dig coax to receiver. (gives you audio and video on your tv. gives you audio to your receiver in case you want surround)

component (RGB) from your dvd to your tv. optical/dig coax to receiver. (not sure if you want audio to your tv from the dvd, if you do, add rca stereo cables to tv)

component (RGB) from your PS2 to your tv. optical/dig coax to receiver. (not sure if you want audio to your tv from the dvd, if you do, add rca stereo cables to tv)


this is what i would suggest instead of that method:
jluv said:
No. The best option would be to turn the speakers on your TV completely off and use your surround sound receiver for all of your sound. You can turn it down or even set it to stereo playback if you just have some kind of thing against surround sound. Even this way, it will sound much better than the built-in speakers in your TV.

With your setup, I would run HDMI and optical cables from each source (DVD player, satellite box, game system, etc) output directly to your receiver inputs and then run an HDMI cable from your receiver output to your TV input. Program your receiver remote to power your TV on and off, and if you can, to change channels on the satellite box and control the DVD player as well. Use your surround sound receiver every time you watch anything. The only thing I ever do to my TV is turn it on and off.
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
16,774 Posts
Discussion Starter · #19 ·
jluv said:
No. The best option would be to turn the speakers on your TV completely off and use your surround sound receiver for all of your sound. You can turn it down or even set it to stereo playback if you just have some kind of thing against surround sound. Even this way, it will sound much better than the built-in speakers in your TV.



Basically, yes. You still need to run an optical (or digital coax) cable from the source to the receiver in addition to the HDMI. They do make better receivers that do true HDMI "switching" (not just "pass-through") and they will take the sound from the HDMI cable and process it correctly. This just makes for simpler wiring and easier control from the remote. Also, HDMI will carry a full 7.1 signal and support TrueHD, but don't worry about that anyway since your receiver is not on that level.

With your setup, I would run HDMI and optical cables from each source (DVD player, satellite box, game system, etc) output directly to your receiver inputs and then run an HDMI cable from your receiver output to your TV input. Program your receiver remote to power your TV on and off, and if you can, to change channels on the satellite box and control the DVD player as well. Use your surround sound receiver every time you watch anything. The only thing I ever do to my TV is turn it on and off.

EDIT: With the PS2, I don't think you can do HDMI. You can still get a cable that connects from the PS2 to component video inputs (red/green/blue) on the receiver, and couple that with the optical audio cable.

Ok that sounds like the best option. My reciever remote can control the tv, not sure about the cable box though.

So I will run hdmi, and optical from dvd, and cable box to the reciever, and run hdmi to the tv for video, and turn the tv speakers off.

I already have a component cable for the ps2.

Sounds like I need to buy a couple optical cables and one more hdmi to get it all done, but I want it to work the best and most efficient.

Thanks for the help.
 

·
yes, jluv
Joined
·
17,073 Posts
Juiceweezl said:
If you are plugging HDMI from say DVD to receiver, then you shouldn't need an optical cable too. If you go DVD to TV and then to receiver, then yes you will need an optical cable.
Most of the entry-level stuff nowadays does HDMI pass-through, which means if you connect a DVD player (for example) to your receiver using an HDMI cable, it will send the video through to the TV, but it will not process the sound coming through the HDMI cable. You still have to connect an audio cable. It's really a pain in the butt, imo.

Once you step up a little in price, you get receivers with true HDMI switching, and they will send video to the TV and also process the audio from the HDMI cable. There is no need for an additional optical cable with this setup.

This is my understanding. I could have it mixed up.

My current receiver does not do HDMI pass-through or switching. I've been in the market (sort of, just browsing) for something new and there is a definite price jump between the two, and I think this is why. If someone can confirm or correct me, it would be much appreciated.
 
1 - 20 of 25 Posts
Top