Originally Posted by Hollywood
So you finally conceed that Bush is the better player?
You throw up that picture of Young as if Bush doesn't have his own National Championship. I see that selective memory of yours is working again. For someone who doesn't care about the Heisman, you sure threw a fit about it when your lover didn't win it.
Doak Walker award = Davey O'brien award
Heisman > Maxwell
No, I didn't conceed anything. I stated that anyone with half a brain knows that VY DOMINATED at the hardest position in football and outplayed 2 Heisman Trophy winners in the biggest game of them all.
No selective memory here. I just know that USC played a weak stick OU team which shouldn't have been in the title game in the first place. Not much of a game or a win there.
The Doak Walker Award most certainly does not equal the Davey O'Brien. Being a RB isn't anywhere near as hard as being a QB and there were plenty of RB's who had significantly better #'s, across the board, than Bush. That could not be said for VY and other QB's.
The Maxwell is given to the "College Player Of The Year" meaning there is nobody better than that one player for that year and is usually given to the Heisman trophy winner. We all know that if the Heisman is done after the National Championship, like it should be, then Bush wouldn't have even been in the final 3 with his pathetic peformance in the Rose Bowl. There have been plenty of shaft jobs when it comes to the Heisman, but that one tops them all and that more than anything is why it was a big deal.